How Wine Experts Rate & Review Wine Clubs

ubs are quickly becoming one of the most popularthe club performed.
enrollment and gift activities associated with theWine Education
food and beverage industry. A wine club is not aOne reason that many people decide to enroll in a
"set in stone" arrangement and they are availablewine club is for the newsletters and printed
in an enormous number of styles and options.information that accompanies their monthly or
There are clubs dedicated to California wines andseasonal shipments. Generally they will discuss the
there are those that focus entirely ongrapes, region and particular vineyard where the
Champagnes or Sparkling wines. The choices arewine was produced. This is not all "fluff", but is
almost limitless, but it is a good idea to investigateintended to educate the member about the wine
some of the wine club reviews before making aindustry and its practices.
choice.All of this is important because it can really help to
Even though most wine clubs use a panel oftrain their palette and enable them to recognize
experts to make their monthly or seasonalthings like bouquet, flavors and aromas. For
selections there may still be some issues with theinstance, you might purchase a bottle of wine that
club's choices, so it's important to do your ownwas aged in oak. It could have a very distinctive
research or read reviews. Wine club reviewsflavor, but as a novice you would not be able to
analyze the following areas:say, "oh, it is the oaky overtones that I am
Quality of Winedetecting". A good wine club will provide such
This is, of course, a major factor in the successtraining, and a good wine club review will praise
of any wine club. If the members receivethe club for delivering these materials.
unpopular or "clearance" items they will probablyAdditionally, a wine club review should scrutinize
not enjoy their membership as much as thosethe club’s educational materials for food
who receive specially selected vintages.pairing information. Wine is not always intended to
Unfortunately there are some clubs that do utilizebe sipped without the benefit of food and many
discounted bottles and vintages as a portion ofpeople are unaware of the best food and wine
each month's shipment. This is usually quickly andpairings. A wine club review should indicate if this
easily identified by the critic who will comment oninformation is included along with every shipment.
every single selection.Value
Additionally, any critic is going to have some goodAny wine club review should let the consumer or
knowledge and background about the type ofpotential customer know if the wines and
wines the club has promised and will be able to leteducational materials come at a reasonable value.
potential members know if the vintages selectedFor example, if a club makes a habit of delivering
match the criteria of the club, or its standards.substandard vintages, the wine club review should
For example, if a club promises the best Californiabe able to identify this fact and alert a consumer
"boutique" wines, a knowledgeable expert will beto the lesser value of such a membership.
able to point out any discrepancies in theAdditionally, it requires the comprehensive
selections.knowledge of an expert to know if a certain type
All of these factors can affect the overall qualityof wine club is actually providing a valuable service
of the wines delivered to the members. Generally,to clients. For instance, a club dedicated to
the wine club reviews will itemize the traditionalenhancing the value of a cellar will offer premium
characteristics of wine on a bottle by bottle orcellaring vintages at a good cost. A wine club
vineyard by vineyard basis. Most reviews rely onreview will point out if this is true or if it fails to
the classic "gold star" system to identify how wellmeet such clear cut terms.